Castellano shoes are leather loafers with no laces, a strap of leather stitched across the instep (the saddle) and a hand-sewn moccasin toe. Spanish men have worn them for generations, but they are not Spanish in origin: they come from the moccasins of Native North American peoples, were reworked by a Norwegian shoemaker in Aurland and became famous in the United States as penny loafers. The name "castellano" comes from a family of Madrid shoemakers, the Castellanos, who made them popular in the 1960s.
In this guide you'll find their history with dates, the different versions (penny, tassel, buckle, leather or rubber sole), why a good pair lasts for years and how to wear them with a suit, with chinos or with jeans.
What is a castellano shoe?
A castellano is a dress loafer: you slip it on without laces, the front is made of one piece of leather that wraps the foot from below, and a second piece, the apron, is stitched on top with a visible seam. Across the instep it has a detail: in the classic model, a leather strap with a half-moon slot, known in Spain as the antifaz; in others, tassels or a metal buckle.
It differs from other loafers in being more structured and more formal: a driving moccasin is soft and has rubber pebbles on the sole, and a boat shoe has a lace running round the heel and a light rubber sole. The castellano has a heel, a firm sole and smooth, often polished leather, which lets it go with a suit.
Where castellanos come from: from Norway to the United States
The story starts a long way from Castile. These are the most widely accepted milestones:
- Native American moccasins. The castellano's construction, with the leather wrapping the foot and the toe stitched on top, is that of the moccasin worn by Native North American peoples.
- Aurland, Norway, early 20th century. Shoemaker Nils Gregoriusson Tveranger, who had learnt his trade in the United States, went back to his village, Aurland, and combined the moccasin with traditional Norwegian footwear. Around 1908 he presented his first design, which won a diploma at the Bergen exhibition in 1910, and around 1930 he launched the "Aurland moccasin", later known as the Aurland shoe.
- The United States, 1930s. The Norwegian shoes caught the eye of Americans travelling in Europe, and in 1936 G.H. Bass of Maine launched its own version: the Weejuns, a name that, according to the most common explanation, comes from "Norwegians". Its signature detail was the leather strap across the instep with a small slot.
- The name penny loafer. Loafer refers to how easy a laceless shoe is. The penny is credited to East Coast college students who, in the 1950s, slipped a one-cent coin into the slot of the strap. It's the most widespread story, though it isn't documented with certainty.
By the 1950s the penny loafer was a staple of American college style, the Ivy look, and from there it spread around the world.
How they reached Spain and why they're called castellanos
In Spain the name has an owner. The Castellano family opened their first shop in Madrid in 1942, on calle Hermosilla, where they started as a repair workshop and became known for country boots and made-to-measure shoes. In the 1960s, the family's second generation created a loafer that all of Madrid began calling "castellanos", after the family surname. Since foreign models were hard to find at the time, the brand ended up as the generic name for this kind of shoe in Spain, as has happened with other brands that became everyday words.
So there's no need to look for roots in Castile: the design is Norwegian and American, and the name comes from Madrid.
The castellano in Spain: a shoe for generations
Since then the castellano has become one of the most recognisable shoes in the Spanish man's wardrobe. Grandfathers, fathers and sons have worn it, and it's a familiar sight at school, at university, at the office and at daytime weddings. The reason it caught on is simple: it's as comfortable as a moccasin, goes on and off without laces and is still formal enough to wear with a jacket. Brown with jeans, black with a grey suit or burgundy with chinos, it's the shoe that sorts out almost any day of the year.
Types of castellano shoes
Penny castellano (antifaz)
The classic model: the leather strap stitched across the instep with its half-moon slot. It's the most versatile and the one that works best with a suit. If you're only going to own one pair of castellanos, make it this one.
Tassel castellano (borlas)
Borlas are tassels: two small leather ornaments with fringes that hang from a decorative lace running round the opening of the shoe. In English they're called tassel loafers. They're credited to the actor Paul Lukas, who in the late 1940s asked American shoemakers for a loafer with tassels; Alden put it into production from 1950 and Brooks Brothers added it to its range in 1957. A little more eye-catching than the penny model, it looks particularly good with a blazer and chinos, though it also goes with a suit.
Castellano with a buckle or metal detail
Instead of the strap it has a buckle or a metal bar across the instep. It's the boldest version, more for town and a smart weekend than for an office suit.
Leather sole or rubber sole
The sole is the other big choice. A leather sole is the traditional one: slimmer, more elegant and more breathable, and the right one for a suit shoe. A rubber sole grips better on wet ground, keeps out more cold and stands up better to everyday walking. Many castellanos are made with both options.
The versions compared
| Version | What it looks like | Formality | What to wear it with |
|---|---|---|---|
| Penny (antifaz) | Leather strap with a half-moon slot across the instep | High | Suit, blazer, chinos and jeans |
| Tassel (borlas) | Two leather tassels hanging from a decorative lace | Medium-high | Blazer and chinos; a suit too |
| Buckle or metal detail | Buckle or metal bar instead of the strap | Medium | Chinos, jeans, a jacket without a tie |
| Leather sole | Thin, traditional leather sole | Most formal | Suit, office, daytime weddings, dry weather |
| Rubber sole | Non-slip, harder-wearing sole | Slightly less formal | Everyday wear, rain, winter, lots of walking |
Handmade and built to last
A good castellano is still largely made by hand, because the moccasin construction demands it: the front piece and the apron are hand-stitched round the toe, and that seam is what gives the shoe its shape and character. Our brown leather castellanos and black leather castellanos are handmade in Spain, with a penny strap, a moccasin-stitched toe and a polished finish, and you can choose them with a leather or a non-slip rubber sole.
With good leather and a little care, castellanos last many years: the leather moulds to your foot as you wear them, develops its own shine and, in many cases, the sole can be replaced by a cobbler when it wears down. To make them last:
- Don't wear them two days in a row. Leather needs a day to release moisture.
- Use wooden shoe trees so they keep their shape and creases don't set in.
- Use a shoehorn. With no laces, the heel suffers if you force your foot in.
- Feed and polish the leather every few weeks with cream in the right colour.
- If they get wet, let them dry away from the radiator, with paper inside.
How to wear castellano shoes
With a suit, for work
A penny castellano with a leather sole goes perfectly with a suit, especially in offices where people dress classically but not rigidly. Choose black with a charcoal or navy suit on the most formal days, and dark brown with a navy or mid-grey suit the rest of the time. The trousers should fall cleanly onto the shoe without bunching, and the socks should be dark, over the calf and matched to the trousers. Finish with a good tie: there are ideas in our guide to wearing a tie with a suit by suit and shirt colour and in how to build a wardrobe for wearing a suit every day. For evening or very formal events, a lace-up shoe is the better choice.
With a blazer and chinos
This is its natural territory. Beige, grey or navy chinos, an oxford or striped shirt and a navy blazer with brown castellanos, penny or tassel, is the Friday office uniform and the go-to for weekend lunches. If you want to add a tie to this look, see how to wear smart-casual with a tie.
With jeans
With dark straight-leg jeans, a white or blue shirt and a knitted jumper, brown castellanos look put-together without trying. Let the jeans finish right at the ankle or with a small turn-up. In summer, with no visible socks (use no-show socks); in winter, with wool socks in a colour from the outfit.
Belt and colours
The usual rule: the belt the same colour as the shoes, or very close. Black castellanos with a black belt; brown with a brown belt. You can see all our models in the men's leather shoes collection.
Frequently asked questions
Why are they called castellano shoes?
After the Castellano family, Madrid shoemakers with a shop since 1942, who in the 1960s created a loafer that became popular under their surname. The name became the generic word for this kind of loafer in Spain. It has nothing to do with an origin in Castile.
What's the difference between a castellano and a loafer?
The castellano is a type of loafer: the dress version, with a firm sole, a heel and a leather strap, tassels or a buckle across the instep. "Loafer" or "moccasin" covers the whole family, which also includes driving shoes, boat shoes and soft house moccasins.
What is a penny loafer?
It's the English name for the castellano with a strap. According to the most common story, in the 1950s American college students slipped a one-cent coin (a penny) into the slot in the leather strap.
Can you wear castellanos with a suit?
Yes. A penny or tassel castellano in black or dark brown with a leather sole works very well with a suit for the office or a daytime wedding. For evening or very formal occasions, a lace-up shoe is better.
Which sole is better, leather or rubber?
Leather is more elegant and breathable, and the best match for a suit. Rubber grips better on wet ground and stands up better to daily wear. If you walk a lot or live in a rainy city, rubber is the practical choice.
Do you wear castellanos with or without socks?
With a suit, always with dark, over-the-calf socks. With chinos or jeans in summer, you can wear no-show socks so it looks as if you're going sockless.
How long do castellano shoes last?
Well-made leather castellanos last many years if you rotate them with other shoes, use shoe trees and look after the leather. When the sole wears down, it can often be replaced by a cobbler.